Keir Starmer’s Proposal for Outdoor Smoking Ban Met with Opposition from Pubs
Keir Starmer, the leader of the Labour Party, has sparked controversy within the hospitality industry and among political opponents with his plans to introduce major restrictions on outdoor smoking. While the Prime Minister has not denied the proposals, they could potentially prohibit smoking outside pubs, restaurants, and other public spaces, including pavements. These potential restrictions would be in addition to existing plans to gradually phase out smoking altogether.
The idea of restricting outdoor smoking has been met with strong opposition from the Conservative party, with critics arguing that it is a form of social control. Priti Patel, a prominent Conservative politician and potential candidate for party leadership, went as far as to label the proposed restrictions as “beyond stupid.” The pub industry has also expressed concerns, warning that such measures could have a negative impact on a sector that is still recovering from the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic.
On the other hand, health experts have voiced their support for the proposed outdoor smoking ban, citing the significant health risks associated with tobacco use. Polling data has shown that the majority of the population, across various demographic and political groups, are in favor of the ban, with the exception of Reform UK supporters.
Details of the proposed ban were leaked to the media, revealing that it would extend to outdoor smoking outside pubs, restaurants, clubs, universities, children’s play areas, small parks, and possibly even shisha bars. It remains unclear whether vaping would also be included in the restrictions. The measures are expected to be included in a forthcoming tobacco and vapes bill, which aims to gradually phase out smoking by prohibiting the sale of tobacco to individuals born after January 2009.
While public health matters are within the jurisdiction of devolved governments, the proposed restrictions would apply only to England, with other UK nations having the option to adopt similar measures. During a visit to Paris, Keir Starmer emphasized the need to address the preventable deaths caused by smoking, which he described as a burden on the healthcare system and taxpayers.
Despite the likelihood of some modifications following consultations, government ministers are reportedly supportive of many of the proposed ideas. However, members of the hospitality industry, particularly pub owners, have raised concerns about the potential economic impact of the ban. Kate Nicholls, the CEO of UKHospitality, highlighted the possibility of “serious economic harm” to venues and called for a thorough discussion with affected parties before any legislation is enacted.
William Lees-Jones, the head of JW Lees Brewery, expressed surprise at the lack of consultation with the industry regarding the proposed ban. He warned that such measures could be detrimental to business and could result in the closure of many pubs. Similarly, Clive Watson, chair of the Inda Pubs group, criticized the idea as “bonkers” and stressed the importance of stability for the pub industry.
Tim Martin, chair of JD Wetherspoon, downplayed the potential impact of the ban on business but raised concerns about government interference in individual liberties. Dr. Layla McCay of the NHS Confederation praised the progress towards eliminating smoking, citing it as a leading cause of preventable illness in the UK.
Conservative MPs have shown mixed reactions to the proposed ban, with some supporting the gradual phasing out of smoking while others oppose it. Priti Patel, a vocal critic of the outdoor smoking curbs, argued that the restrictions could harm businesses and divert police resources. Robert Jenrick, another Conservative leadership contender, criticized Keir Starmer, claiming that he does not understand the country.
The Liberal Democrats have called for a balanced approach to the proposed ban, considering its potential impact on hospitality venues. YouGov polling data indicates that a majority of the public supports the ban, with 58% in favor and 35% against. The figures were consistent among Conservative voters as well.
A spokesperson for the Department of Health and Social Care emphasized the government’s commitment to reducing the harms of smoking, highlighting the significant health and financial costs associated with tobacco use. The potential ban on outdoor smoking is seen as a step towards creating a smoke-free Britain.
Following the ban on smoking in enclosed public places and workplaces in 2007, there was a notable decrease in hospital admissions related to smoking-related illnesses. The charity Action on Smoking and Health reported a 12.3% drop in hospital admissions for childhood asthma in the year following the implementation of the ban.
In conclusion, Keir Starmer’s proposal for an outdoor smoking ban has ignited a heated debate within the hospitality industry and political circles. While supporters argue that it is a necessary step to protect public health, opponents raise concerns about the economic impact on businesses. As discussions continue, it remains to be seen how the proposed ban will be implemented and what effects it will have on society as a whole.
