Young Mother Criticized for Taking Baby to Manchester Riot
A young mother in Manchester has faced criticism after taking her toddler to a riot at a hotel housing asylum seekers. Nevey Smith, 21, admitted to throwing water over police during the disturbance on July 31, with her 20-month-old child in a pram. The incident occurred amid nationwide unrest following a stabbing at a holiday club in Southport. Smith claimed that she “lost her temper” while on a day out with the baby’s grandmother, leading her to participate in the chaotic events at the Holiday Inn.
Judge’s Response and Sentencing
During her sentencing at Manchester Crown Court, Judge Patrick Field KC expressed disbelief at Smith’s actions, particularly in exposing her child to such dangerous circumstances. He described her as “misguided, naive, and immature,” questioning her decision to involve her toddler in the riot. The judge emphasized that Smith’s actions demonstrated a lack of concern for her child’s safety and criticized her for choosing to participate in the disorder despite being responsible for a young child.
Judge Field ultimately decided to spare Smith an immediate jail sentence, opting instead for a community order. As part of her sentence, Smith will be required to attend reviews at a women’s problem-solving court and complete 100 hours of unpaid work. While acknowledging that Smith’s role in the riot was minimal and peripheral, the judge emphasized the need for her to learn from the experience and mature as a parent.
Defending Smith’s Actions
In her defense, Smith’s lawyer, Daniel Calder, explained that she had not intended to participate in the protest that day. He described her involvement as a result of a spontaneous decision made while passing by the riot. Calder emphasized that Smith had not expressed discriminatory views and lacked awareness of what an asylum seeker is. He portrayed her actions as a misguided and impulsive response rather than a deliberate attempt to engage in violence.
Despite her participation in the riot, Smith’s defense team highlighted her lack of involvement in throwing bricks or encouraging others to do so. They argued that her actions were not premeditated and that she had been caught up in the moment without fully understanding the consequences. Smith’s mother, Vanessa Smith, who was also present at the protest, admitted to violent disorder and is awaiting sentencing.
In conclusion, the incident involving Nevey Smith taking her baby to a riot in Manchester has raised concerns about parental responsibility and the impact of civil unrest on vulnerable individuals. The judge’s decision to impose a community order on Smith reflects a recognition of her youth and lack of prior criminal behavior. Moving forward, it is essential for individuals to consider the safety and well-being of children in all circumstances, particularly during times of social upheaval.
